Here at Enlightened, we live for those lightbulb moments when the idea for a new flavor strikes. As we introduce those new creations for you to enjoy, sometimes we have to change our lineup to make room. (Parting is such sweet sorrow… literally!)
While flavors that have gone into retirement won’t be listed on our Store Locator, they may still appear in stores for a limited time, so if you spot them in the freezer case, be sure to stock up! You can also order discontinued flavors directly to your door while supplies last via Ice Cream Source.
Hoping to see a favorite of yours make a comeback? There’s always the chance that a discontinued flavor will return based on popular demand—let us know what you’re craving at email@example.com. We’ve also included some suggestions for new flavors to explore below. With dozens of pint and bar options to dig into, there’s a lot to discover!
If you loved Bananas Foster
Try… Monkey Business!
We’ll take any excuse to go bananas. Any Bananas Foster fan is bound to love our dairy-free Monkey Business pint.
If you loved Birthday Cake
Looking for something straight from the bakery in ice cream form? Snickerdoodle takes inspiration from the classic sugar cookie. (Sprinkles optional, but recommended.)
If you loved Butter Pecan
Try… Toasted Almond bars!
Like a scoop of Butter Pecan, these bars are full of roasty, toasty, nutty flavor.
If you loved Caramel Oatmeal Cookie Crunch
Try… Sea Salt Caramel!
If a silky caramel swirl in ice cream makes all the difference for you, Sea Salt Caramel (available in both pints and bars, as well as dairy-free bars) will hit the spot.
If you loved French Toast
Try… Movie Night!
Like something a little off the beaten path? What you need is Movie Night: Popcorn ice cream with a caramel swirl and chocolate bits.
If you loved Frozen Hot Cocoa
Try… Frozen Hot Cocoa bars!
The same fluffy marshmallow swirl you loved in our Frozen Hot Cocoa pint is also in these delicious, 90-calorie bars.
If you loved Fudge Brownie
Try… Brownies & Cookie Dough!
Those chewy and craveable brownie chunks can still be found (with the added bonus of cookie dough and chocolate chips) in our Brownies & Cookie Dough pint.
If you loved Glazed Donut
Try… Ooey Gooey Cinnamon Bun!
If you’re in a breakfast-for-dessert mood, dairy-free Ooey Gooey Cinnamon Bun is a pint you’ll want to stock up on by the dozen.
If you loved Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip
Try… Chocolate Peanut Butter!
If you agree that peanut butter and chocolate are the ultimate duo, you’ll love this rich chocolate ice cream swirled with creamy peanut butter.
If you loved Red Velvet
Love an ice cream pint that’s creamy, chocolatey, and 70 calories per serving? Chocolate’s got all your bases covered.
If you loved S’mores
Try… Cookies & Cream!
The taste of campfire s’mores always brings back happy memories. If you get nostalgic for sandwich cookies dunked in a tall glass of milk, Cookies & Cream is the pint for you.
If you loved Toasted Almond
Try… Toasted Almond bars!
Our Toasted Almond flavor lives on in bar form.
If you loved Triple Shot Espresso
Try… Triple Shot Espresso!
You’re not seeing double: Dairy-Free Triple Shot Espresso has none of the dairy, but all of the bold coffee flavor you love.
If you loved Birthday Cake bars
For something festive, check out our dark-chocolate-dipped bars, sprinkled all over with crunchy almond pieces.
If you loved Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip bars
Chocolate ice cream, creamy peanut butter, and the perfect single-size portion: These bars have everything that peanut butter and chocolate fanatics are looking for.
If you loved Red Velvet bars
If rich and chocolatey is the name of the game, satisfy your craving with a Fudge bar.
Ready to go track down your new favorite? Search near you using our Store Locator!
Comments are closed